Form: Label and description + Error Test

test

Label & description standalone (1)

Input 1

Input 1 help text

Label & description standalone (2)

Input 2

Input 2 help text

Label & description standalone + error (3)

Input 3

Input 3 help text
Input 3 error

Label & description inside label, with described by (4)

Input 4
Input 4 help text

Label & description inside label, without described by (5)

Input 5
Input 5 help text

Label, description & input inside label, without described by (6)

Input 6
Input 6 help text

Label & description with aria-labelledby standalone (7)

Input 7

Input 7 help text

Label, description & input inside label, without described by, after the input (8)

Input 6
Input 6 help text

Results

Expectation	JAWS 2024 with Chrome	JAWS 2024 with Firefox	JAWS 2024 with Edge	NVDA with Chrome	NVDA with Firefox	Narrator on Edge	VoiceOver on Mac with Safari 17.1.2 (19616.2.9.11.12), Mac OS 14.1.2 (23B92)	VoiceOver on iOS with Safari 17.1.2	Talkback on Android with Chrome
Announce Label	1 through 7	1 through 7	1 through 7	1 through 7	1 through 7	1 through 7	1 through 7	1 through 7	Not testest
Announce Label & description / error	1–3 announces: `<label>` edit blank describedby 4 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank describedby 5 + 6 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank 7 announces: Labelledby + edit blank, -> Ignores label text	1–3 announces: `<label>` edit blank describedby 4 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank describedby 5 + 6 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank 7 announces: Labelledby + edit blank, -> Ignores label text	1–3 announces: `<label>` edit blank describedby 4 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank describedby 5 + 6 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank 7 announces: Labelledby + edit blank -> Ignores label text	1–3 announces: `<label>` edit blank describedby 4 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank describedby 5 + 6 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit blank 7 announces: Labelledby + edit blank -> Ignores label text	1–3 announces: `<label>` edit, has autocomplete describedby Blank 4 announces: `<label>` edit, has autocomplete describedby blank 5 + 6 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit, has autocomplete blank 7 announces: Labelledby + edit, has autocomplete blank -> Ignores label text	1–3 announces: `<label>` edit describedby 4 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit describedby 5 + 6 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit 7 announces: Labelledby + edit, -> Ignores label text	1–3 announces: `<label>` edit text -> Ignores described by 4 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit text describedby 5 + 6 announces: `<label>` + describedby edit text 7 announces: Labelledby + edit text -> Ignores label text	1–4 announces: `<label>` “Description” + describedby Text field 4 announces: `<label>` + describedby “Description” + describedby Text field 5+6 announces: `<label>` + describedby Text field 7 announces: Labelledby -> Ignores label text	Not testest

Screen reader and OS Version Details

JAWS 2024.2310.70 with Chrome 119.0.6045.200
JAWS 2024.2310.70 with Firefox 120.0
JAWS 2024.2310.70 with Edge Edge 119.0.2151.93
NVDA 2023.3.0.29780 with Chrome 119.0.6045.200
NVDA 2023.3.0.29780 with Firefox 120.0
Narrator on Windows 11 Pro, 10.0.22631 with Edge 119.0.2151.93
VoiceOver (macOS) 14.1.2 on Safari 17.1.2 (19616.2.9.11.7)
VoiceOver (iOS) 17.1.2 on Safari 17.1.2